Clinique

rating tier poor

brand rating & evaluation

Clinique

brand rating & evaluation
overall rating: Poor
rating tier poor

Our ratings are based on a scale from 1 (Avoid) to 5 (Top Choice).

See how we rate.


The Shifting Gaia rating evaluates brands based on sustainable practices, ingredients and materials, and social responsibility, among others. Below are a few factors influencing this brand's score:

overview

sustainability
4.2 out of 10
non-toxic
7.0 out of 10
social responsibility

about

Clinique is a global beauty brand producing skincare and makeup.

Highlights

  • 2025 recyclable/refillable packaging targets
  • FSC-certified secondary packaging
  • Carbon-neutral U.S. shipping

sustainability

Rotating arrow
Sustainability
score:
4.2 out of 10

details:

Packaging

Clinique has set substantial packaging sustainability goals for 2025, aiming for 75% of all packaging to be recyclable, refillable, reusable, recycled or recoverable and ensuring 100% of secondary packaging is Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certified. Despite these commitments, Clinique’s current packaging still relies heavily on virgin plastic, with only modest use of recycled content.


Ingredient Sustainability

All Clinique formulas are now free of parabens, phthalates, and artificial fragrance. The company (via Estée Lauder Companies) also pledged to source palm oil and derivatives responsibly. Despite these steps, an analysis of Clinique’s product ingredients reveals extensive use of petrochemical and non-renewable materials. Many formulas contain mineral oil, petrolatum, silicones, and synthetic polymers (e.g. nylon-12 in powders, polyethylene in lip products) that are fossil-fuel derived and non-biodegradable.

Energy Use and Footprint


Estée Lauder Companies achieved net zero carbon emissions for its direct operations (Scopes 1 and 2) and 100% renewable electricity globally by 2020. This means Clinique’s manufacturing sites and offices are largely powered by renewables or offsets. Clinique’s own digital infrastructure is also addressed. Notably, Clinique.com is powered by renewable energy. Clinique contributes to mitigation by offering carbon-neutral shipping for all U.S. e-commerce orders, funding forest conservation offsets to neutralize delivery emissions.

Waste Management

Waste reduction is an area of partial progress for Clinique. The brand’s primary strategy is improving packaging recyclability rather than fundamentally redesigning the product lifecycle. However, beyond packaging, Clinique offers few circular solutions.

Business Model

Clinique operates on a traditional beauty business model that shows little alignment with “slow” or circular consumption principles. The brand maintains a steady flow of product launches, seasonal collections, and promotions.

non-toxic

Rotating arrow
Non-toxic
score:
7.0 out of 10

details:

As of 2025, all Clinique products are free from parabens, phthalates, and added fragrance. An analysis of five representative product INCI lists supports Clinique’s safety emphasis: formulas rely on generally safe, well-studied components like emollient plant oils and butters, glycerin and hyaluronic acid (humectants), gentle surfactants, and approved colorants. Clinique also avoids chemical sunscreens in many skincare products; where it does include them (e.g. octinoxate in a foundation), it balances with physical filters (zinc oxide, titanium dioxide). A few ingredients might raise flags for very cautious consumers or environmental health advocates.

social responsibility

Rotating arrow
Social responsibility
score:

details:

As part of Estée Lauder Companies, Clinique adheres to a Supplier Code of Conduct that addresses labor rights and working conditions in the supply chain. This code explicitly prohibits forced labor, child labor, harassment, and discrimination, and expects suppliers to comply with wage and hour laws. The company reports that it conducts regular audits and risk assessments of suppliers to ensure compliance, sometimes in partnership with platforms like EcoVadis. However, Estée Lauder does not publish a full list of Clinique’s ingredient or packaging suppliers.

Clinique does not have a cruelty-free certification, and its animal welfare policies lag behind more ethical brands. The official stance is that Clinique “is committed to the elimination of animal testing” but will comply with local laws, meaning the company allows animal testing where required by regulators (notably in mainland China).

Clinique shows a meaningful level of community engagement and philanthropy, particularly focused on women’s health and education. The brand’s signature “Clinique Difference Initiative” partners with nonprofits worldwide to support women and girls in need.