Eye Makeup

Shop Vegan + Organic Eye Makeup. Explore Shifting Gaia’s Eye Makeup collection from our top rated Makeup Brands, Shop Butter Me Up Organics Eye Makeup, Clover by Clove + Hallow Makeup, featuring organic and cruelty-free products to define and enhance your eyes. From eyeliners and mascaras to eyeshadows and brow products, each formula is designed for long-lasting wear and vibrant results.

Eye Makeup
24 products
24 products
Sort by:
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
CREAMY EYELINER CREAMY EYELINER

IDUN Minerals Inc.

CREAMY EYELINER

$21.00
$21.00
EYEBROW PENCIL EYEBROW PENCIL

IDUN Minerals Inc.

EYEBROW PENCIL

$21.00
$21.00
CREAMY INLINER SAND CREAMY INLINER SAND

IDUN Minerals Inc.

CREAMY INLINER SAND

$21.00
$21.00
MASCARA SILFR MASCARA SILFR

IDUN Minerals Inc.

MASCARA SILFR

$28.00
$28.00
Zero Waste Brow Gel™ Zero Waste Brow Gel™

Izzy Zero Waste Beauty

Zero Waste Brow Gel™

$27.95
$27.95
Zero Waste Mascara™ Zero Waste Mascara™

Izzy Zero Waste Beauty

Zero Waste Mascara™

$27.95
$27.95
Eyelash Growth Serum Organic / Grow your lashes long naturally / Long Lashes / Eyelash Serum / Lash Growth Eyelash Growth Serum Organic / Grow your lashes long naturally / Long Lashes / Eyelash Serum / Lash Growth

Butter Me Up Organics

Eyelash Growth Serum Organic / Grow your lashes long naturally / Long Lashes / Eyelash Serum / Lash Growth

$24.95
$24.95
Organic Eyeliner / Organic Eye Makeup / Eye Coal / Butter Me Up Organics Organic Eyeliner / Organic Eye Makeup / Eye Coal / Butter Me Up Organics

Butter Me Up Organics

Organic Eyeliner / Organic Eye Makeup / Eye Coal / Butter Me Up Organics

$19.95
$19.95
Brow Wax & Growth Serum Brow Wax & Growth Serum

River Organics

Brow Wax & Growth Serum

From $19.99
From $19.99
Black Vegan Zero-Waste Mascara Black Vegan Zero-Waste Mascara

River Organics

Black Vegan Zero-Waste Mascara

From $19.99
From $19.99
MINERAL SINGLE EYESHADOW MINERAL SINGLE EYESHADOW

IDUN Minerals Inc.

MINERAL SINGLE EYESHADOW

$16.00
$16.00
LIQUID EYELINER KOL LIQUID EYELINER KOL

IDUN Minerals Inc.

LIQUID EYELINER KOL

$24.00
$24.00