Fontana Candle Co.

rating tier top choice

Fontana Candle Co.

brand rating & evaluation
overall rating: Top Choice
rating tier top choice

Our ratings are based on a scale from 1 (Avoid) to 5 (Top Choice).

See how we rate.


The Shifting Gaia rating evaluates brands based on sustainable practices, ingredients and materials, and social responsibility, among others. Below are a few factors influencing this brand's score:

certifications:

Made Safe
Leaping Bunny

learn more about these certifications*

overview

sustainability
7.5 out of 10
non-toxic
10.0 out of 10
social responsibility

about

Fontana Candle Co. is a U.S.-based brand selling all-natural, non-toxic candles and home fragrance products.

Highlights

  • Non-toxic ingredients
  • Plastic-free packaging
  • Cruelty-free

sustainability

Rotating arrow
Sustainability
score:
7.5 out of 10

details:

Packaging

All product packaging is plastic-free and designed for recyclability or biodegradability. Candles are sold in reusable glass jars (with metal lids for jar candles or tin containers for travel candles) instead of plastic. Soaps and newer wax melt products are packaged in FSC-certified paper cartons printed with soy-based inks. The company recently switched from glass jars to paper boxes for wax melts specifically to eliminate plastic clamshells and reduce waste. Shipping materials are plastic-free as well, using paper padding and cardboard boxes. Fontana goes so far as to postpone product launches if a sustainable packaging solution isn’t feasible; for instance, they held back a foaming hand soap until they could package it in glass rather than defaulting to plastic pumps. 

Ingredient Sustainability

Across these products, Fontana is using materials that fall into the most sustainable categories of our evaluation parameters. Beeswax is a natural wax that burns cleanly and is renewable (especially when sourced from ethical apiaries). It avoids the petroleum inputs and soot of paraffin and the deforestation concerns of palm wax. Coconut oil (used to soften the wax blend) is plant-based and biodegradable. All fragrances come from steam-distilled or cold-pressed essential oils, not from synthetic fragrance compounds. This means no persistent petrochemicals, phthalates, or musk compounds - only botanical ingredients that break down more readily in the environment. For example, the orange, cinnamon, and clove oils in their candle are derived from plants (orange peels, cinnamon bark/leaves, clove buds) which are renewable resources. Notably, Fontana avoids ingredients with known high ecological harm: there are no parabens or plastics, no mineral oils, no palm oil (a common soap base linked to rainforest destruction), and no endangered plant extracts. Their wooden wicks are sourced from FSC-certified mills that plant a tree for every $100 spent, supporting responsible forestry. These choices indicate a preference for responsibly harvested materials and traceability.

Energy Use and Footprint


Manufacturing is done entirely in the United States (Lancaster, PA), which shortens the supply chain and avoids the high emissions of overseas shipping for finished goods. By producing domestically and sourcing many inputs from North America (beeswax from domestic apiaries, wood wicks from FSC mills likely in the US), Fontana reduces reliance on carbon-intensive air freight and long-distance transport.

However, Fontana has not (as of available information) published any greenhouse gas inventory or set targets for emissions reduction. There is no evidence of renewable energy use at their facility or purchase of carbon offsets for remaining emissions.

Waste Management

A standout initiative is their “Imperfect Seconds” program, where candles with minor aesthetic defects (e.g. slight cracks, off-center wicks, or dented tins) are sold at a discount instead of being discarded. This keeps usable products out of landfill and reflects a circular mindset. Fontana hasn’t implemented a formal container return or refill program yet (customers currently reuse or recycle jars on their own).

Business Model

Fontana’s business model leans toward slow, conscious consumption, although it operates within a traditional retail framework to an extent. On one hand, Fontana does not churn out fad-based collections or endless new SKUs each month. Their core product lineup of candles and home scents is relatively timeless and evergreen. Scents are largely classic (lavender, vanilla, citrus, spice, etc.) and remain available year-round, with a focus on consistency and quality rather than fleeting trends.

The brand does engage in seasonal offerings and occasional limited releases, but in a balanced way. They have seasonal scent collections (e.g. Winter Scents or a special “Celebrations” collection for holidays and occasions). These tend to be limited-time scents tied to seasons (like a Pumpkin Spice or Apple Spice candle in fall, or collaborative special edition candles), which create some sense of novelty. However, the seasonal launches are relatively few per year and often return annually.

non-toxic

Rotating arrow
Non-toxic
score:
10.0 out of 10

details:

Every product is formulated to be as safe as possible for human health, and this is validated by rigorous third-party standards. All of Fontana’s candles, wax melts, and soaps are MADE SAFE® Certified, meaning they contain none of the chemicals on Made Safe’s toxicant list (no known carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxins, endocrine disruptors, environmental toxins, etc.). In fact, Fontana’s candles were the first ever to earn this certification, highlighting their leadership in non-toxic home scenting.

They pointedly avoid all the common toxins found in mainstream candles and fragranced products. This means: no paraffin wax (which emits soot and carcinogenic compounds when burned), no synthetic fragrance oils (which often contain phthalates, allergens, and undisclosed chemicals), no lead or metallic wicks (Fontana uses natural wooden or cotton wicks), no dyes (if any color is present, it’s from natural oil tint; most Fontana candles are undyed), and no parabens, petrochemicals, or harmful preservatives. The soaps contain no sulfates or PEGs; the candles contain no solvents or enhancers. Essentially, Fontana has removed every ingredient with a questionable safety profile.

social responsibility

Rotating arrow
Social responsibility
score:

details:

Fair Labor


Fontana is a small, founder-driven company, and while its ethos suggests care for people, there is limited published information on labor practices across its supply chain. On the positive side, Fontana’s own operations are U.S.-based, which means the workers making the candles in Lancaster, PA operate under U.S. labor laws (ensuring at least minimum wage, basic workplace safety standards, and no child labor by law). The company is family-owned and does not rely on outsourced manufacturing in low-wage countries. However, Fontana has not provided detailed public disclosures about labor policies or supplier standards. For example, while they ensure their beeswax is sustainably harvested, there’s no mention if it’s sourced from fair trade cooperatives or simply from conventional beekeepers.

Animal Welfare

Fontana Candle Co. demonstrates a clear commitment to animal welfare in terms of product testing and ingredient ethics, though it does use some animal-derived ingredients. The brand is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified as of 2022, which is the gold-standard assurance that no animal testing is conducted at any stage of product development – neither by Fontana nor its ingredient suppliers. 

Community Engagement

Fontana Candle Co. engages with social and environmental causes in a way that goes beyond just selling products, especially for a small company. They have shown a pattern of community giving and advocacy, aligning their brand with broader issues of public health and environmental wellness.