Lume

rating tier avoid

brand rating & evaluation

Lume

brand rating & evaluation
overall rating: Avoid
rating tier avoid

Our ratings are based on a scale from 1 (Avoid) to 5 (Top Choice).

See how we rate.


The Shifting Gaia rating evaluates brands based on sustainable practices, ingredients and materials, and social responsibility, among others. Below are a few factors influencing this brand's score:

overview

sustainability
1.2 out of 10
non-toxic
5.5 out of 10
social responsibility

about

Lumel (branded as Lume™) is a small skincare and beauty tech brand offering a red-light therapy wand and companion skincare products.

sustainability

Rotating arrow
Sustainability
score:
1.2 out of 10

details:

Packaging

Lume shows no evidence of sustainable packaging initiatives. Product packaging is predominantly conventional plastic: the Red Light Wand kit and serums come in plastic components, the capsule creams are sold in traditional jars, and items like the Multi-Balm stick use standard plastic tubes.

There are no refill systems or circular packaging features. Customers must purchase new containers each time (e.g. buying a new serum bottle rather than refilling an old one). The brand has not mentioned using recycled materials, FSC-certified paper, or compostable alternatives in any of its packaging. 

Ingredient & Material Sustainability

Several components raise sustainability concerns: for example, the Multi-Balm Moisturizer Stick contains polyethylene and other petrochemical derivatives, which are petroleum-based plastics not readily biodegradable. 

The capsule creams use ingredients like Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride (typically derived from palm or coconut) and Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Butter (no fair-trade noted). The Salmon DNA Boba Cream features “Salmon Egg Extract” and “Sodium DNA” from salmon, an animal-derived ingredient whose sourcing (wild-caught vs. farmed waste) is not explained, raising questions about ecological impact on marine life.

Even beneficial plant extracts (aloe, cucumber, meadowfoam, etc.) used by Lumel come with no transparency about their origin or farming practices.

Energy & Carbon Footprint

The brand’s operations are opaque; there are no published carbon footprint measurements, renewable energy usage statements, or carbon offset programs.

Manufacturing of Lume's LED wand and skincare likely involves third-party factories (possibly overseas), yet Lumel does not disclose their location or any efficiency measures. The shipping regions (Middle East, US, etc.) indicate international transport of goods, implying freight emissions that the brand has not addressed publicly. 

Waste Management

 Lume has no visible waste mitigation policies for either manufacturing or post-consumer waste. The brand does not mention how it handles manufacturing waste or if it recycles materials during production. Likewise, there are no take-back or recycling programs for its products’ end-of-life. 

For example, there is no guidance on disposing of the Radiant Renewal Wand once its battery or LEDs fail, implying it could end up in electronic waste streams.

Packaging waste is similarly unaddressed: customers receive items like masks, plastic jars, and tubes without any recycling instructions or incentives to return packaging.

Business Model

Lume’s business model shows elements of conventional, sales-driven commerce with some product longevity benefits. On one hand, the brand’s product lineup is relatively small and “mostly evergreen” – a few core items (wand, serum, capsule creams, etc.) rather than fast-changing collections. This suggests they are not churning out new trends constantly, which aligns with a slower consumption pattern.

The site heavily promotes sales, bundle deals, and subscriptions (e.g. “May Sale”, Christmas bundles, and subscribe-and-save for serums). These urgency-driven promotions and discounts encourage impulse buys and continuous consumption, which contradicts a truly slow, mindful consumption ethos.

non-toxic

Rotating arrow
Non-toxic
score:
5.5 out of 10

details:

Lume excludes parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde-releasers, triclosan, and other high-risk cosmetic chemicals – an important baseline for non-toxicity.Their formulas emphasize generally safe actives: niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, aloe vera, vitamin C derivatives, ceramides, and plant oils - However, a closer look at full ingredient lists reveals the presence of some controversial additives: for example, the Melon Glow Lip Oil contains BHT (Butylated Hydroxytoluene), a synthetic antioxidant that some studies link to potential endocrine disruption or skin irritation. The Multi-Balm stick formula includes polyethylene and polyisobutene, inert polymers that are not toxic to apply, but are microplastics that raise environmental toxicity concerns if they enter waterways.

social responsibility

Rotating arrow
Social responsibility
score:

details:

Fair Labor

There is no public Code of Conduct for suppliers, no mention of worker wages, factory audits, or compliance with labor laws. Unlike ethical brands that share supplier lists or certify fair trade ingredients, Lumel operates with complete opacity in its supply chain. This lack of transparency means we cannot confirm whether workers who make the skincare or the devices are treated fairly, paid living wages, or work in safe conditions.

Animal Welfare

The company has not announced any cruelty-free testing policy – it is not certified cruelty-free, and there is no statement on their site about animal testing. 

Lume uses animal-derived ingredients in multiple products, which is a strike against it from a vegan or animal-welfare perspective. The Salmon DNA Boba Cream contains Salmon DNA and salmon egg extract, meaning fish are the source of those ingredients (commonly, PDRN is extracted from salmon milt, a fish farming byproduct, but the brand gives no detail)

The Multi-Balm Moisturizer includes beeswax, an animal byproduct from honeybees. These ingredients indicate Lume is not vegan, and sourcing them can have welfare implications.

On a positive note, Lume does not use any cosmetic ingredients that are directly the result of animal harm like animal hair, bone, or mammalian byproducts, and it isn’t involved in industries like fur or leather.

Community Engagement

There is no evidence of Lume engaging in any ongoing social or environmental initiatives beyond selling its products. The brand does not advertise donating a portion of profits to charity, partnering with community organizations, or participating in environmental restoration projects.