Rustic Strength

rating tier top choice

Rustic Strength

brand rating & evaluation
overall rating: Top Choice
rating tier top choice

Our ratings are based on a scale from 1 (Avoid) to 5 (Top Choice).

See how we rate.


The Shifting Gaia rating evaluates brands based on sustainable practices, ingredients and materials, and social responsibility, among others. Below are a few factors influencing this brand's score:

certifications:

Leaping Bunny
PETA Cruelty-free

learn more about these certifications*

overview

sustainability
8.9 out of 10
non-toxic
10.0 out of 10
social responsibility

about

Rustic Strength is a family-owned brand producing refillable, non-toxic cleaning, laundry, and personal care products designed to reduce waste and exposure to harmful chemicals.

Highlights:

  • Closed-loop packaging and refills
  • Plant-based, sustainable ingredients
  • Non-toxic formulations
  • Cruelty-free

sustainability

Rotating arrow
Sustainability
score:
8.9 out of 10

details:

Packaging

Rustic Strength’s packaging prioritizes reusability and minimal plastic use. The brand offers glass bottles (24 oz to 1 gal) and durable food-grade plastic jugs (½ gal to 5 gal) that customers can return through the Close the Loop™ program for sanitizing and reuse. Larger 5-gallon “Eco Jugs” contain up to 80% post-consumer recycled plastic, extending their lifespan. By sourcing local glass and using compostable bamboo fiber for paper products, Rustic Strength reduces transport footprint and supports circular systems. The company avoids single-use pumps by selling them separately and reuses shipping materials (shredding old boxes for packing). Packaging components like inks and adhesives are chosen for low toxicity and the brand prints labels on demand to prevent waste. These practices result in almost entirely recyclable or refillable packaging, aligning with a high circularity focus.

Ingredient Sustainability

Across sampled products, none contain known carcinogens, mutagens, or high-risk toxins. The brand explicitly omits a long list of hazardous substances commonly found in mainstream cleaners: no SLS/SLES sulfates, no 1,4-dioxane, no parabens, no phthalates, no formaldehyde releasers, no synthetic dyes, no optical brighteners, and no synthetic fragrances with toxic ingredients. In place of those, Rustic Strength uses naturally derived and food-grade components. For instance, its preservative system relies on ingredients like sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, and benzyl alcohol (phenoxyethanol) in very small concentrations, all considered safe by cosmetic and health standards. Surfactants like decyl glucoside, cocamidopropyl betaine, and olefin sulfonate are rated as mild and non-irritating to skin (with any potential for irritation far lower than harsher detergents like SLS). Many ingredients (aloe vera, glycerin, marshmallow root, etc.) are even skin-beneficial. The inclusion of allergen-free fragrance options (unscented versions and use of phthalate-free fragrance oils or pure essential oils) means customers can avoid sensitizing chemicals; the brand’s fragrances are certified to contain none of California Prop 65 listed toxins

Energy Use and Footprint

All products are made in-house in Missouri and shipped directly to customers or stockists, avoiding the long supply chains and overseas manufacturing that can increase emissions. This domestic, family-run manufacturing (in the Ozarks) means energy use and emissions occur under U.S. regulations, and the brand can closely control processes. However, Rustic Strength has not publicly reported its greenhouse gas emissions or adopted renewable energy for its facilities (no mention of solar, wind, or carbon offsets). Instead, the brand’s footprint strategy focuses on indirect reductions via waste and transport minimization.

Waste Management

The brand has implemented a closed-loop system that significantly cuts waste at multiple stages of the product life cycle. Customers are encouraged to return empty containers via the Close The Loop™ mail-in program, after which Rustic Strength sanitizes and refills the bottles for resale. This reuse program effectively diverts packaging waste from landfills and embodies circular economy principles. In addition, Rustic Strength offers refills and bulk purchasing options for nearly all products (from 16 oz up to 5 gallon buckets and even 30–55 gal barrels), which minimizes the frequency of packaging disposal. Partnerships with zero-waste stores amplify this impact by letting customers refill in person with their own containers, eliminating single-use packaging entirely for those transactions.

In its production facility, Rustic Strength strives for zero waste operations. Surplus materials and would-be waste products are not simply thrown out: the company repurposes and upcycles wherever possible. For example, shipping box scraps and packaging paper are shredded and reused as packing filler for outgoing orders. Unused or slightly imperfect products that cannot be sold are offered free to employees rather than discarded. They also resell or donate excess raw materials and supplies to local businesses and charities, ensuring materials find a second life in the community instead of becoming waste.

Business Model

Rustic Strength’s business model promotes slow, sustainable consumption rather than rapid turnover or trend-chasing. The brand maintains an evergreen product lineup of home and body care essentials (laundry detergents, cleaners, soaps, basic lotions) that are meant to be refilled and used long-term, not frequently replaced with “new” versions. New product launches are infrequent; Rustic Strength tends to expand via new scents or slight formula improvements rather than completely new categories or short-lived gimmicks.

non-toxic

Rotating arrow
Non-toxic
score:
10.0 out of 10

details:

Rustic Strength’s formulations are deliberately crafted to be human-safe and gentle, using ingredients with low toxicity profiles and avoiding virtually all chemicals of concern for human health. Across the five sample products, none contain known carcinogens, mutagens, or high-risk toxins. The brand explicitly omits a long list of hazardous substances commonly found in mainstream cleaners: no SLS/SLES sulfates, no 1,4-dioxane, no parabens, no phthalates, no formaldehyde releasers, no synthetic dyes, no optical brighteners, and no synthetic fragrances with toxic ingredients. In place of those, Rustic Strength uses naturally derived and food-grade components. For instance, its preservative system relies on ingredients like sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, and benzyl alcohol (phenoxyethanol) in very small concentrations, all considered safe by cosmetic and health standards. Surfactants like decyl glucoside, cocamidopropyl betaine, and olefin sulfonate are rated as mild and non-irritating to skin (with any potential for irritation far lower than harsher detergents like SLS). Many ingredients (aloe vera, glycerin, marshmallow root, etc.) are even skin-beneficial. The inclusion of allergen-free fragrance options (unscented versions and use of phthalate-free fragrance oils or pure essential oils) means customers can avoid sensitizing chemicals; the brand’s fragrances are certified to contain none of California Prop 65 listed toxins.

social responsibility

Rotating arrow
Social responsibility
score:

details:

Fair Labor

Rustic Strength provides decent labor conditions within its own operations and shows some awareness of ethical sourcing, though its labor practices are largely unverified by third parties. As a small U.S. manufacturer, the company directly employs over 40 people from the local community in Missouri, offering jobs in a family-friendly work environment. Employees operate under U.S. labor laws (ensuring minimum wage, workplace safety, and other legal protections).

In terms of the broader supply chain, Rustic Strength’s small scale and emphasis on local sourcing mitigate some typical labor risks.

Animal Welfare

Rustic Strength demonstrates a strong commitment to animal welfare. No animal testing is conducted by the company or its ingredient suppliers. The entire Rustic Strength line is certified cruelty-free, carrying the Leaping Bunny certification as confirmation that no animal testing is used at any stage of product development.

Community Engagement

Rustic Strength partakes in charitable giving and community support programs. The company has made donations to many community outreach initiatives and emergency housing programs in the area. This implies that a portion of profits or products are regularly directed to local shelters, charitable drives, or families in need.