Brand Rating:

Naturium

Poor

4/10

Score 4/10

Our ratings are based on a scale from 1 (Avoid) to 5 (Top Choice).
See how we rate.

Rated: May 04, 2026
Category: Beauty care
Subcategory: Skincare

Overview:

Sustainability 4.8/10

Non-toxicity 5.5/10

Naturium is a Los Angeles-born mass-market clinically-effective skincare brand founded in 2019 by content creator Susan Yara in partnership with beauty incubator The Center, acquired by e.l.f. Beauty in August 2023.

Highlights:

Cruelty-free and vegan
Parent company e.l.f. Beauty maintains 100% renewable energy at directly managed sites
Plastic Bank partnership

Sustainability

score : 4.8/10

Packaging

Naturium's packaging strategy combines parent company e.l.f. Beauty's documented sustainable packaging investments (33% packaging intensity reduction since 2019, 400 tons of packaging eliminated annually through lightweighting, 50% recycled content commitment by 2030) with brand-specific PCR content (15% across Naturium serums and washes, growing) and partnership-driven recycling infrastructure (Plastic Bank).

Still, the catalog is plastic-dominated with limited use of glass, aluminum, or paper-based primary containers. Products are predominantly packaged in plastic tubes, plastic bottles, and plastic jars across the face skincare and body care lines. The primary plastic packaging across the Naturium catalog remains predominantly virgin plastic in non-PCR-targeted product categories. The brand has not implemented a refill program at any product level.

Ingredient Sustainability

The overall ingredient sustainability profile reflects a science-forward mass-market skincare brand that has invested in formulation efficacy and accessibility but has not invested significantly in sustainable ingredient sourcing infrastructure. The structural exclusions are real (no parabens, sulfates, mineral oil, fragrance in many products), but the chemistry that fills the formulation slots is predominantly petrochemical-derived synthetic chemistry rather than sustainably sourced natural alternatives.

Naturium's formulation philosophy emphasizes biocompatible, dermatologist-tested formulas with "natural botanicals with potent actives for clinically effective results." However, the catalog includes substantive petrochemical-derived synthetic ingredients across formulations. Regarding palm-derivable ingredients, the parent company's commitment to 100% RSPO palm oil by 2027 represents structural commitment but is forward-dated, meaning current formulations may include uncertified palm-derived ingredients.

Energy Use & Carbon Footprint

Naturium's energy and carbon profile is anchored by parent company e.l.f. Beauty's structural commitments including 100% renewable energy at directly managed sites, SBTi-approved emission reduction targets for Scope 1 and 2 emissions, published annual Impact Report with quantitative emissions reporting, water conservation programs with measurable savings, and ingredient supply chain emissions reduction through Fair Trade Certified manufacturing partnerships.

The parent company has SBTi-approved emission reduction targets for Scope 1 and 2 emissions. Science-Based Targets initiative validation is the gold-standard third-party verification for corporate climate commitments, requiring targets aligned with 1.5°C climate science. SBTi validation for Scope 1 and 2 represents structural climate accountability at the parent company level. The parent company publishes a detailed annual Impact Report with quantitative environmental performance data.

The parent company's Fair Trade Certified manufacturing facilities support broader supply chain emissions accountability, as Fair Trade Certification includes environmental responsibility criteria alongside labor practices.

Still, Naturium-specific emissions data is not disclosed separately from parent company. The parent company SBTi targets cover Scope 1 and 2 only, not Scope 3, which represents the bulk of beauty industry emissions. No Climate Neutral Certification is held at brand or parent company level.

Waste Management

Naturium's waste management profile combines parent company e.l.f. Beauty's packaging intensity reduction (33% reduction since 2019, 400 tons eliminated annually through lightweighting), Plastic Bank partnership for ocean plastic removal, water conservation infrastructure with measurable savings, and biocompatible formulation philosophy emphasizing efficacy preservation.

The Plastic Bank partnership is structurally significant for waste management beyond conventional recycling. The 2 million bottle removal target represents commitment to address waste already in marine environments rather than only addressing forward-going packaging. The partnership creates measurable impact metrics through ocean plastic removal volumes.

The parent company's water conservation program saved over 500 cubic meters of water in 2025. Water conservation is a structural waste reduction in beauty manufacturing where water use is typically substantial.

The brand has not implemented a refill program at any product level. No take-back program exists for empties at brand level (contrast with Eva NYC's Pact Collective and TerraCycle partnerships in this evaluation series). No concentrated formulas are offered. No upcycled byproduct ingredient lines are explicitly featured (despite some bioactive fruit extracts that could be byproduct-sourced from food industry).

Business Model

Naturium's business model combines parent company e.l.f. Beauty's stated mission-driven positioning with structural commercial dynamics (publicly traded on NYSE, acquired Naturium for $355 million with growth-oriented integration, multiple recent acquisitions including rhode in 2025, frequent product launches, mass-market scale across 19,500+ retail doors equivalent through e.l.f. Beauty portfolio) that operate counter to slow-consumption principles.

Non-toxicity

score : 5.5/10

The exclusions are real and meaningful for human health: parent company e.l.f. Beauty avoids 2,500+ ingredients across its brand portfolio, and Naturium specifically formulates without parabens, sulfates, mineral oil, denatured alcohol, and synthetic fragrance across many products. The brand publishes complete INCI lists per product on its website, which is meaningful disclosure transparency that supports informed consumer decision-making.

The fragrance-free positioning across many products is the single most consequential human-health choice the brand has made. Synthetic fragrance is one of the most documented sources of allergic reactions, sensitization, and irritation in cosmetics, and avoiding it across multiple core products structurally reduces sensitization risk for users with reactive skin.

The base preservation system across the catalog is conventional but generally well-tolerated. Phenoxyethanol is the primary preservative used across most products at concentrations below the EU-restricted 1.0% threshold for leave-on products for children. It's paired with Caprylyl Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Sorbic Acid, Benzoic Acid, and Potassium Sorbate as co-preservatives. These are standard industry preservation choices that are well-tolerated for most users. The notable exception is the Multi-Peptide Moisturizer, which uses Chlorphenesin alongside Phenoxyethanol. Chlorphenesin has documented endocrine disruption considerations and is restricted in some jurisdictions, making it an unusual choice.

The Dew-Glow Moisturizer SPF 50 uses chemical UV filters that warrant specific attention from a human-health standpoint. The active ingredient combination is Avobenzone 3.0%, Homosalate 10.0%, and Octisalate 5.0%. Homosalate at 10% is the maximum permitted concentration in the United States but exceeds the EU regulatory threshold of 7.34%, which the EU set based on potential endocrine disruption. Avobenzone has documented stability concerns (it degrades in sunlight without stabilizers) and has been associated with allergic reactions in some users.

Polysorbates appear across multiple formulations (Polysorbate 20, 60, and 80 in different products). Polysorbates are well-tolerated for direct skin contact but the manufacturing process can leave trace 1,4-dioxane contamination, a documented human carcinogen. The brand has not disclosed 1,4-dioxane testing transparency for its Polysorbate-containing products, which is a meaningful gap given that several formulations use multiple Polysorbate variants.

Social Responsibility

score : 6.2/10

Fair Labor

Naturium's fair labor profile is anchored by parent company e.l.f. Beauty's industry-leading Fair Trade Certified manufacturing infrastructure (the first and only beauty company with Fair Trade Certified facilities, with 73% of all e.l.f. Beauty product units made in 6 third-party Fair Trade Certified facilities), Fair Trade Community Development Funds benefiting 3,000+ workers in 2025, parent company published annual Impact Report with workforce transparency, and parent company industry-leading board diversity (78% women, 44% diverse). The parent company's published annual Impact Report includes workforce transparency data.

A third party assessment notes: "Labor practice transparency shows significant disclosure gaps with no independent verification systems" for Naturium specifically, while acknowledging the broader parent company Fair Trade infrastructure. This represents a transparency gap at brand level despite the parent company's Fair Trade infrastructure.

Limitations exist. The Naturium brand has not separately disclosed which of its specific products are made in Fair Trade Certified facilities (the 73% figure applies to e.l.f. Beauty corporate aggregate). Naturium-specific manufacturing partner identity is not transparently disclosed at brand level. Naturium-specific wage transparency is not published.

Animal Welfare

The brand is third-party cruelty-free certified. While the specific certifying body (Leaping Bunny, PETA, Cruelty-Free International) is not consistently identified in primary sources reviewed, the cruelty-free positioning is structurally consistent across brand communication. The catalog is fully vegan.

Community Engagement

Naturium's community engagement profile combines parent company e.l.f. Beauty's structural philanthropic commitment (2% of prior year's profits donated to changemaking causes annually, $2.5 million in FY2025), parent company Fair Trade Community Development Funds benefiting 3,000+ workers, parent company Change the Board Game coalition advocacy, brand-specific Plastic Bank partnership creating jobs in coastal communities, and parent company "give an e.l.f." campaign for boardroom diversity, animal welfare, women's empowerment, and other causes.